Skip to content
Fieldstone Water Co.

Water sources · Private wells

Private Wells on Long Island: What No Report Covers

A private well pumps groundwater from under the property, usually from the shallow Upper Glacial aquifer, with no supplier, no treatment and no required testing between the owner and the tap. The water itself is the same aquifer the public systems use. The difference is that nobody checks it unless you do.

At a glance

Pros and cons

Advantages

  • No chlorine, chloramine or disinfection by-products unless you add them.
  • No water bill and no dependence on a utility's mains.
  • You decide what to treat and how.
  • Where the aquifer is clean, well water can be excellent: cold, soft on the East End, and free of additives.
  • County and state programs test Suffolk wells at no charge.

Trade-offs

  • No required testing, no published report, and no one responsible but the owner.
  • Shallow wells see nitrate, pesticides and septic influence first.
  • PFAS and 1,4-dioxane have been found in wells near legacy sites.
  • Bacteria risk from wellhead or casing problems.
  • Iron, manganese and hardness are common and untreated by default.
  • Pump, pressure tank and electrical failures are yours to fix; no water in a power outage without a generator.
  • Buyers and lenders increasingly ask for a recent test at sale.

Where the wells are

Public mains never reached every street. On the East End, in parts of the Pine Barrens, along stretches of the North Shore from Great Neck to Oyster Bay and east through Huntington and Smithtown, and on Fire Island and Shelter Island, homes rely on their own wells. Suffolk County's health department puts the number in the tens of thousands.

On this site, communities where most of the land sits outside any public water service area are shown as private wells, and communities split between mains and wells are shown as mixed. Both are measured from the service-area boundaries the state supplies to EPA.

What shows up in Long Island well water

Because most private wells draw from the shallow aquifer, they see what the land above them does. The county's own testing program, running since 1979, prioritises agricultural areas for pesticides and their breakdown products. Nitrate from fertilizer and septic systems is the most common issue island-wide. Iron and manganese stain fixtures in many Suffolk wells.

The industrial legacy is here too. PFAS from firefighting foam and 1,4-dioxane from solvent use have been found in private wells near former airfields, fire-training sites and industrial areas, and New York now offers free PFAS testing to private well users through a state pilot program that Suffolk County administers.

Bacteria are the one problem public systems almost never have and private wells sometimes do, usually from a cracked casing, a flooded wellhead or a nearby cesspool.

Testing: what and how often

The U.S. EPA and New York State both tell well owners to test every year for coliform bacteria and nitrate, and after any flooding, repair or change in taste, odor or color. A broader panel, including metals, volatile organic compounds, pesticides and PFAS, is worth doing when you buy the house and every few years after.

Suffolk County's Office of Water Resources runs a private well testing program for existing homes that provides a comprehensive analysis and recommendations; call 631-852-5810 or apply through the county portal. Separately, the state's private well PFAS pilot offers free PFAS testing and, where a well is at or above the state standard, rebates toward treatment or a public water connection.

What to do

If this is your water

  1. 1.Get the free county test if you are in Suffolk

    The Office of Water Resources program tests existing private wells and sends recommendations. The state PFAS pilot adds free PFAS analysis and rebates for affected wells.

  2. 2.Test bacteria and nitrate every year

    These two change fastest and matter most. Add a broad panel at purchase and every few years.

  3. 3.Fix the wellhead before the water

    A sealed cap, a casing above grade and distance from the cesspool solve most bacteria problems without any treatment.

  4. 4.Treat in stages, based on results

    Well treatment is a sequence, not a single filter: sediment and iron first, then carbon, then reverse osmosis at the tap for nitrate or PFAS, with disinfection only if bacteria persist. A free in-home test is the starting point.

On this site

Communities mostly on private wells

15 communities are shown as private wells, measured from the service-area boundaries the state supplies to EPA; another 72 are mixed, with mains on some streets and wells on others.

Questions

Common questions

Sources

Start here

Find out what reaches your tap.

A free in-home test measures what is actually in your water, whatever its source, and tells you whether treatment is worth it and when a certified laboratory test is the right next step.